Point of Divergence
I used Chat GPT to rephrase a part of the Wikipedia article
OTL
Even prior to the commencement of the Crusade, the relationship between Eleanor and Louis was deteriorating, and their disagreements only intensified while they were abroad. The main source of discord was Eleanor's alleged involvement with her uncle Raymond, the ruler of Antioch, who aimed to reclaim the nearby County of Edessa—a goal central to the Crusade. Eleanor's support for her uncle's objectives, coupled with what was perceived as "excessive affection" toward him, fueled the discord.
Their journey home, marked by disagreements, took an unexpected turn. Louis and Eleanor, traveling on separate ships due to their disputes, faced an attack by Byzantine ships in May 1149. Although they escaped unharmed, stormy weather diverted Eleanor's ship to the Barbary Coast, causing her to lose contact with her husband for over two months. In mid-July, Eleanor's ship finally reached Palermo in Sicily, where she discovered that both she and Louis were presumed dead. She found refuge with King Roger II of Sicily's servants until the king arrived in Calabria, and she set out to reunite with him. At King Roger's court in Potenza, she received the distressing news of her uncle Raymond's death at the hands of Muslim forces in the Holy Land. This news prompted a change of plans, diverting them to Tusculum to meet Pope Eugene III, who had sought refuge there due to a revolt in the Commune of Rome.
Contrary to Eleanor's hopes for an annulment, Pope Eugene did not grant one. Instead, he attempted to reconcile the strained couple, affirming the legality of their marriage and prohibiting any challenge to it. He even arranged for Eleanor and Louis to share a bed, resulting in the conception of their second child, Alix of France—a daughter, not a son.
The marriage, however, was destined for failure. Lacking a male heir and facing opposition from barons and Eleanor's desire for annulment, Louis reluctantly accepted the inevitable. On March 11, 1152, they met at the royal castle of Beaugency to dissolve the marriage, with Archbishop Hugues de Toucy presiding. The annulment was granted on March 21 by the four archbishops, sanctioned by Pope Eugene, citing consanguinity within the fourth degree as grounds. Although Eleanor was Louis' third cousin once removed, sharing ancestry with Robert II of France and Constance of Arles, their two daughters were declared legitimate. Custody of the daughters was awarded to King Louis, who assured Archbishop Samson that Eleanor's lands would be restored to her.
POD
Contrary to Eleanor's hopes for an annulment, Pope Eugene did not grant one. Instead, he attempted to reconcile the strained couple, affirming the legality of their marriage and prohibiting any challenge to it. He even arranged for Eleanor and Louis to share a bed, resulting in the conception of twins named Alice and William which would prevent the planned annulment of Eleanor.
OTL
Even prior to the commencement of the Crusade, the relationship between Eleanor and Louis was deteriorating, and their disagreements only intensified while they were abroad. The main source of discord was Eleanor's alleged involvement with her uncle Raymond, the ruler of Antioch, who aimed to reclaim the nearby County of Edessa—a goal central to the Crusade. Eleanor's support for her uncle's objectives, coupled with what was perceived as "excessive affection" toward him, fueled the discord.
Their journey home, marked by disagreements, took an unexpected turn. Louis and Eleanor, traveling on separate ships due to their disputes, faced an attack by Byzantine ships in May 1149. Although they escaped unharmed, stormy weather diverted Eleanor's ship to the Barbary Coast, causing her to lose contact with her husband for over two months. In mid-July, Eleanor's ship finally reached Palermo in Sicily, where she discovered that both she and Louis were presumed dead. She found refuge with King Roger II of Sicily's servants until the king arrived in Calabria, and she set out to reunite with him. At King Roger's court in Potenza, she received the distressing news of her uncle Raymond's death at the hands of Muslim forces in the Holy Land. This news prompted a change of plans, diverting them to Tusculum to meet Pope Eugene III, who had sought refuge there due to a revolt in the Commune of Rome.
Contrary to Eleanor's hopes for an annulment, Pope Eugene did not grant one. Instead, he attempted to reconcile the strained couple, affirming the legality of their marriage and prohibiting any challenge to it. He even arranged for Eleanor and Louis to share a bed, resulting in the conception of their second child, Alix of France—a daughter, not a son.
The marriage, however, was destined for failure. Lacking a male heir and facing opposition from barons and Eleanor's desire for annulment, Louis reluctantly accepted the inevitable. On March 11, 1152, they met at the royal castle of Beaugency to dissolve the marriage, with Archbishop Hugues de Toucy presiding. The annulment was granted on March 21 by the four archbishops, sanctioned by Pope Eugene, citing consanguinity within the fourth degree as grounds. Although Eleanor was Louis' third cousin once removed, sharing ancestry with Robert II of France and Constance of Arles, their two daughters were declared legitimate. Custody of the daughters was awarded to King Louis, who assured Archbishop Samson that Eleanor's lands would be restored to her.
POD
Contrary to Eleanor's hopes for an annulment, Pope Eugene did not grant one. Instead, he attempted to reconcile the strained couple, affirming the legality of their marriage and prohibiting any challenge to it. He even arranged for Eleanor and Louis to share a bed, resulting in the conception of twins named Alice and William which would prevent the planned annulment of Eleanor.