Regeneration- The Jacobites Restored(a Successful Jacobite Timeline)

Aberdeen was a loyal Whig City.

The Lord Provost and the people supported the rights of King George II to the maintenance of his rights as the rightful King and his efforts to protect their freedoms and their religion. It was only natural that the few who opposed this would remain silent as the Duke of Cumberlands Army camped their in preparation for the move north.

One of those people was Ailsa Fisher, a local prostitute who performed her duties to Lt.General Thomas Howard, a position which she used before dawn on the fifth of April to discover the governments plans for challenging the rebel forces, and the route they planned on taking. This was to prove a decisive moment in the rebellion in the year 1746 as within minutes of her leaving, she contacted her brother, Andrew Fisher, who immediately set out on horseback with outmost speed towards the lines of the Jacobite force, the deception not being discovered until it was too late.

……………………………………………….

Around one o'clock in the afternoon on the same day, Mr. Fisher reached the Jacobite headquarters, to be greeted by a sense of panic. Many of the lower level commanders were aware the Government Army sent to face them outnumbered their own by around two to one. The news brought by Fisher brought the relief they sorely required.

Within the next three to four days, Cumberland had planned on setting march for Nairn. On his way to Nairn stood one mighty obstacle, the River Spey. The Jacobite Army had now received notification as to where the Dukes force would attempt to ford the river. At the order of Lord George Murray and with the consent of the Jacobite Council of War, the rebel army began their march to the Spey where they would lie in wait for the Dukes Army. With any luck, they would have one to two days advantage on the Government force. Thus was set in motion the Battle of the Spey.

…………………………………………………..

At Dawn on the ninth of April, the Government Army marched out of Aberdeen, looking to retake Inverness and then set camp in Nairn in a bid to flush out the Pretenders rag-tag band. Cumberland did so in confidence, but was conscious that the Spey provided a natural obstacle to final victory, something which became clear as the Army reached it at nine o'clock in the morning of the tenth of April. As such, the order was given to split his force in three when crossing the river, each a mile apart.

The river was wide, knee deep at the deepest point and although not hugely quick required the concentration of any man crossing it. The Northern flank had a tree-line at the opposite bank. Behind this were the bulk of the Jacobite forces who laid in wait for the Dukes Army. The Duke, present of the northern crossing was aware of the danger but this was a required option, and as such, he was amongst the first to cross the river and as such, he hid this fact from his men.

As the first two-hundred men crossed the river, with another thousand in the process of crossing, the Jacobite force attacked, charging the wet, vulnerable government soldiers. Taken by surprise, the Dukes force didn't have a chance to prepare themselves for battle. The element of surprise among the men was complete and within fifteen minutes, over five-hundred government solders were butchered and the Commander of the force lay wounded on the field, to be taken captive by the Jacobite force. Those on the other bank of the river flew in the confusion and barbarity of the assault. They were met in turn by the remainder of Prince Charles force under the command of Cameron of Lochiel, who completed the rout of the northern crossing. Inside twenty minutes, 3,000 of the Governments 8,000 troops were neutralised including their attillery. The first stage of the Battle was firmly won by the Jacobites. Cumberland was being transported to Inverness. The battle was not over yet though. Not by a long shot.

……………………………………………..

Down the river, the noise and confusion of the northern attack gave rise to panic amongst the other two crossings, both of whose men and commanders heard the confusion and shot of the northern attack., On the southern flank, commanded by the Earl of Abermarle showed a huge level of caution, for fear he would share the fate of Col. John Cope at Prestonpans, retreating his men back across the river and marching north to meet the chaos from the other bank of the river, factoring in that “the Highland Charge is naught when met with water.” A runner was sent north, but with caution urged to find out if it was the northern wing or the middle column who were attacked.

Not waiting for such confirmation and with the certain knowledge of which section of the line was under attack, the middle line of Government force under the command of General John Huske carried on with the crossing, albeit with increased haste as they were determined to come to the aide of their comrades in arms.

…………………………………………….

Lord George Murray being aware that there were three crossings ordered and in the expectation that the other two forces would have crossed the river, ordered his men south to meet the expected assault. Forty-five minutes after the conclusion of the hostilities of the first section of the battle, the Jacobite Army crashed into the Royal army which was heading north in lines of fifty men, given the narrowness of the land. Both sides, exhausted by the exertion of their endeavours thus far fought with a huge ferocity. Fifteen minutes into this brutal exchange, the front lines broke and troops began to flee. Huske, in a bid to urge his men on pushed forward on his charger, only to be met with a musket-ball to the head which killed him outright.

Some of the fleeing men went back across the river, heading south where after ten minutes, they met Abermarles force. Upon hearing that two-thirds of the Army were defeated, he ordered a retreat back to Aberdeen to regroup.

The Battle of the River Spey was over, the Jacobites were victorious.
 
The retreat to Aberdeen was a troubled one. The Army had been smashed. Once more, the son of the Pretender had been triumphant in the face of odds which favoured his opponent. Abermarle knew that a Court Martial awaited him upon his return for not putting up a fight against the Jacobite forces, but given the circumstances of fleeing troops informing him of a massacre, what option did he have? It was now only a matter of time before the Rebels marched on Aberdeen to complete their victory. As such, redemption could only come for him in the defence of the city. Not for him, the fate of Hawley or Cumberland, who he was unaware was still alive.

They returned to their camp just outside Aberdeen on the dawn of the tenth, and as soon as they reached the city a muster was made of the returning men. Of the 8,000 who set off for Nairn, only 2,827 returned. Many were likely in the Highland countryside attempting to make their way back to the city, leaving aside the captured or the dead. All the artillery was lost alongside the wages to pay the men under his command. To make matters worse, knowledge of the events of the Battle were piecemeal, to the extent that the number of rebel soldiers who engaged the Government Army varied considerably depending on which officer was met. All that could be certain was that an attack was coming.

Inside the City itself, a panic arose. Many of the population opted to flee, clogging the roads to Angus. The Port was similarly busy. A local company of Watchmen swore they would remain to defend their city from being over-run but the likelihood was that the Jacobites now had overwhelming numerical supremacy as a result of the encounters of the previous day. The commander of the HMS Terror was charged with setting sail for Edinburgh and then London to inform the Government that the Rebels now had the whip hand in the engagement.

……………………………………………………..

Inverness was the complete opposite of Aberdeen. Church Bells rang aloud with joy as the Princes Army marched their prisoners through the streets of the City to the Castle where they were to be kept prisoner. The rejoicing in the streets could not be avoided and the optimism lost on the long retreat north from Derby was rekindled by this one engagement.

Upon arrival in the castle, thousands of Government soldiers were given a hard option by order of Prince Charles and the Rebel Council of War. They could either switch allegiance and fight for the Pretender, or they could rot in the cramped confines of the Castle. Of course, given the mores of the day, officers were to be given preferential treatment and of the commanders of the Government Army, not a one switched sides to the Rebels.

The men, however shaken and without confident were not all as loyal. Some 361 of the 4,000 Prisoners switched sides, the promise of pay and adequate rations being too good to turn down. Of this number, the majority came from Loudens Highlanders and the 2/1st Regiment of Foot. They were immediately put into training for the Princes Army.

All the while, Donald Cameron of Locheils Highlanders scoured the countryside around Speyside looking for Government soldiers who flew the field but never managed to meet up with the main force. This led to a number of minor skirmishes, but also resulted in the capture of another 600 men.

……………………………………………………..

Four days after the engagement at the River Spey, the main force of the Jacobite Army decided to press home the advantage gained in the prior engagement and set foot for Aberdeen. It was believed that once the Government Army was defeated, the path would be re-opened for a triumphant return south to Edinburgh, bolstered by the captured artillery confidence was high in all ranks.

In the march, they were aided by Abermarles caution. Crossing the River Spey without incident, they were on the outskirts of the city in the early hours of the fifteenth. This led to a running engagement between Abermarle and the Princes forces and, much to the horror of the remaining inhabitants of Aberdeen street to street fighting. In the street-fighting the advantage of the disciplined British Soldier was negated against the brutal cleaving tactics of the Highlanders who also had the advantage of first blood resulted in the City falling in the early hours of the morning. Amongst the dead lay the Earl of Abermarle.

This was no repeat of the Battle of the Spey however. The Princes Army lost some 700 men to the entirety of the Government Army. Measured against this was the performance of the men who had deserted from the Government Army who had fought in the main with honour. The knowledge that they would be executed for treason should they be captured doubtless on the back of their minds.

……………………………………………………………….

On the same day as Aberdeen falling, news of the defeat in the North of Scotland reached London. Whilst it was too far from the front-line for panic to set in, the capture or death of the Kings son set aloft a wave of anger. The result of it all was now clear. Troops would need to be returned from the Continent. The fate of the Kingdom was more important than wars abroad after all. This reaction would have heartened the people of Edinburgh, a city which had already been occupied the previous year.

The next day, upon hearing the news of the Battle of the Spey in Scotland, King Louis XV of France ordered a day of celebrations throughout the Kingdom.

The Capital of Scotland now lay open to the Jacobite Army.
 
This is good, although I have the feeling that Aberdeen was broadly sympathetic towards the Jacobites - at least, it was during the 1715 rebellion, and the entirety of the North East was a Jacobite stronghold in that rebellion.
 
This is good, although I have the feeling that Aberdeen was broadly sympathetic towards the Jacobites - at least, it was during the 1715 rebellion, and the entirety of the North East was a Jacobite stronghold in that rebellion.
Both Aberdeen and Dundee helped fund the Government Army during the rising, Dundee more so, but still. Cumberland even became Chancellor of Aberdeen Uni.
Interesting...
I prefer the Corries if you are looking for music about the rising.

I am working on the next two parts, which I will post at once tomorrow or thursday.
 
Last edited:
During “the Killing Times” of eighty years earlier, the Young Pretenders Grandfather had used Highland troops, the so-called “Highland Host” to suppress the liberties and religious freedoms of the people of the lowlands. Fear of a return to those times was what caused the City to fund a Battalion of Government troops, who were slaughtered, almost to a man, a week earlier, causing the River Spey to run red. The deaths of their sons, the loss of their money and fear of the loss of their Protestant religion what is what caused the elders of the city to decide that the only honourable course of action would be its defence.

As such, fear gripped the City of Dundee as news of the march south reached the city the following day.

Those that could not pay the ferryman for crossing to Fife clogged the road east as they headed to Perth. Both the Royal Bank of Scotland and the Bank of Scotland in the city emptied their vaults and made haste for Stirling, where they would store their reserves until the danger had passed. The truth was grim though. There was now no force capable of facing the Pretender on his march to the Capital of Scotland.

The Lord Provost, Alexander Lundie, a stout man in his forties raised the local Watch, who numbered some 306 men, of whom only 83 had seen service in the Kings Army. The choice he faced was grim. Surrender the city or fight in vain and risk the sacking of Dundee. In the end, the memory of General Moncks sacking of the city was enough. After much begging from the tradesmen of the city who remained, he agreed to put out an order of no resistance.

As such, on April 24th 1746, the army of the Young Pretender marched to the sound of the Pipes down the Overgate of Dundee to the silent observation of the population who remained.

Dundee had fallen. After two days, during which time some 100 men were pressed into service in the Jacobite Army, the march to Edinburgh was resumed.

…....……………………………………………………………..

The feeling in London was one of dismay but not immediate panic.

Everything thrown against the Young Pretender had been repelled. The son of the King was now in bondage to the rebel forces and the French Army had amassed at Dunkirk, although the common feeling was that they would not venture to invade unless the rebel army was in sight of the Capital. For the first time since William the Bastard had invaded seven hundred years ago, England was at risk. If London fell, the Kingdom would be lost. This was fully appreciated by all.

Forces were in the process of being returned from the Continent, but this would take time. The fear was that if too many were returned too quickly, the war in Europe would be lost for no reason but if they were too slow, a French invasion would almost certainly occur.

Faced with this quandry, the Prime Minister, Henry Pelham ordered as few troops as he dare be returned to England. Until the situation improved, there was a grudging acceptance that Scotland and potentially the North of England were lost.
 
The feeling in London was one of dismay but not immediate panic.
I think this sentence captures exactly what the feeling would be - broadly similar to what it had been the previous year before Charlie's army turned back at Derby.

Just one point/question: I get the impression you're writing this as if from a contemporaneous viewpoint and I'm not sure they would use the term 'William the Bastard' - he was still viewed very positively as 'William the Conqueror' in the 18th century (right up to the early 20th, in fact). However, as I always say, it's your TL, so write what you want...I'm enjoying it regardless! :)
 
Both Aberdeen and Dundee helped fund the Government Army during the rising, Dundee more so, but still. Cumberland even became Chancellor of Aberdeen Uni
This leaflet from Aberdeen City Council suggests that the picture in Aberdeen was, at least, a bit more mixed than that:

http://www.aberdeencity.gov.uk/web/files/LocalHistory/jacobite_trail_leaflet.pdf

Back in the day Aberdeen University was split into two colleges. From memory, it was Marischal College that was more Protestant and may have been the one that made Cumberland Chancellor, but both colleges were in favour of the Jacobites in the 1715 uprising, and were purged shortly thereafter.

Not a big issue but I don't think you can say Aberdeen was a Whig city in the same way that Glasgow, for example, was.
 
This leaflet from Aberdeen City Council suggests that the picture in Aberdeen was, at least, a bit more mixed than that:

http://www.aberdeencity.gov.uk/web/files/LocalHistory/jacobite_trail_leaflet.pdf

Back in the day Aberdeen University was split into two colleges. From memory, it was Marischal College that was more Protestant and may have been the one that made Cumberland Chancellor, but both colleges were in favour of the Jacobites in the 1715 uprising, and were purged shortly thereafter.

Not a big issue but I don't think you can say Aberdeen was a Whig city in the same way that Glasgow, for example, was.
There isn't as much mentioned for support of the 45 as to support for the 15 in the leaflet. Indeed, it states that after Cope marched south at the start of the rising, taking the cities arms with him, Aberdeen was occupied by rebels who took the local dignitaries prisoner, the local civic leaders pointedly refusing to toast the Jacobite cause. Of the Jacobite prisoners taken in 1746(less than 100), it is noted that those held were servants and lower class citizens of the city. This is a pointed difference between the 45 rising and the one of thirty years earlier.

In times before full representative democracy was introduced to Britain, I think the backing of a large majority of those who own businesses, run the council, the professional classes and tradesmen opposing the Jacobites ensure the city ticks the box as being solidly for one side. Had I been talking the 1715 rising, I would have agreed but times moved on. I would also say that I agree, Abedeen was not Whiggish to Glaswegian levels. I would argue Glasgow was more Whiggish than Manchester though, so it's not really a fair comparison.

One thing I would add is that outside the Gàidhealtachd, the division in Scotland, in religious terms, wasn't so much Catholic v Protestant, but an internal Protestant division of Presbyterianism v Episcopalian. The issue was that the Kirk was recognised within the Union as the national Church of Scotland, whereas the Episcopalians, who had a strong following in the North East were in more inclined to back the Jacobites. In spite of this however and due to a rather effective use of state repression between the 1715 rising and the 1745 rising, the actual number of Episcopalians declined and the number of followers of the Kirk increased greatly.
 
The March to Edinburgh was more of a procession than a military march. Whilst avoiding Stirling and a potentially inconvenient siege, the Jacobite Army reached the outskirts of the city in just three days, marching through the city in triumph on the thirtieth of April with Charles once more taking up residence in Holyrood Palace.

The divide in the leadership of the Rebel Army became clear at this point however. The Prince wanted urgently to march into England. In the War Council, he was outvoted however. Lord George Murray had successfully persuaded the council that they would only march south with French troops supporting them and until that point they would build a more professional force to consolidate their position in Scotland.

A ship was to be sent to France with haste to make clear the Jacobite position. Further to this, news was to be sent to James requesting he make a return to Scotland. It was hoped that the return of the Old Pretender would help drive more men to the side of the Jacobites. This would take several weeks however as the Royal Navy still controlled the seas around Scotland.

…………………………………………..

News reached the British forces fighting on the Continent on the fifth of May. Already in a dangerous position, the withdrawal of yet more troops to Britain was seen as something which could tip the war against them. This led to the diplomatic action of how the Dutch and Hapsburgs would take the news that the British were to be further depleted.

Sadly, there was no alternative.

In England, men were being pressed into service. Numbers were needed more than anything. Time was of the essence. It was commonly conceived that if the Jacobites moved south at this point, the Kingdom was at risk of falling.

...……………………………………………….

The Governor of Edinburgh Castle, Lord Mark Kerr was in a state of despair. For the second time, the Bastion on the Rock was under siege. Never in the history of the fortress had it fallen to military might, so he was secure in that sense, and in terms of supplies, he had ample store to last some six months. The presence of Admiral Byng in the Forth gave him heart and each day the practice was established of firing a solitary shot at one o'clock each day from the castle with a responding shot from the Royal Navy Warship to keep the castle updated that the situation was unchanged. Three shots in return were to indicate a change. In spite of this though, they were trapped and fully aware there was no immediate relief at hand. Kerr determined that he would not go down as a second Lundy. Just as Derry had held, he was of the belief that Edinburgh Castle would hold too.

……………………………………………………….

The Governor of Stirling Castle, the Earl of Louden lacked the good fortune of the sight of the open sea. The sight on the fifth of May of a thousand Highlanders, led by Cameron of Locheil moving on the town of Stirling from the south alongside 100 Cannon captured from the Government forces was to lead to panic as the realisation that Edinburgh had once more fallen set in. Even, as before Stirling surrendered, efforts by the rebel forces to parley with the government forces in the Castle were rebuffed.

Louden had held firm a year earlier, he would do so again. A resolute man of strong protestant convictions, he was determined to follow his duty.

This time however, the rebel gunners were to be in a position to use the castle for training. The siege of Stirling was not to be a pretty one. The Gentle Locheil was to show his sharper side.

The plain truth of it was that these two fortresses were now the last bastions of Hanovarian rule north of the River Tweed.
 
Last edited:
Never in the history of the fortress had it fallen to military might
Are you maybe considering another use of guile as in Randolph's capture of it in 1314?
when the one o'clock gun was fired
The one o'clock gun at the castle wasn't installed until the 19th century. Are you saying that it was the RN ship firing at one o'clock each day? I thought they used bells for time signals?

Sorry to be picky - I only comment on TLs I'm enjoying, so please take this as a 'thank you, please continue!'.
 
The one o'clock gun at the castle wasn't installed until the 19th century. Are you saying that it was the RN ship firing at one o'clock each day? I thought they used bells for time signals?

Sorry to be picky - I only comment on TLs I'm enjoying, so please take this as a 'thank you, please continue!'.
Gah! I'll update the tale forthwith.

As to the other part, we'll have to see...
 
Top