Recent content by thaddeus

  1. China as a Axis Supporter WWII

    IDK @Carl Schwamberger it seems China-Japan would be in some sort of conflict, that would be nearly impossible to avoid? I had scribbled an alt.history for a successful KMT defense of Wuhan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Wuhan, with a modest German air corps instead of the historical...
  2. The Germans build carriers, instead of battleships, prior to WW2

    a realistic assessment shows the KM would have to fight a u-boat war and how can it best be supported? my speculation would be for a fleet of oil tankers, as Germany is both importing oil and chronically short of currency reserves, they could barter transportation for oil. they could add...
  3. Hitler's Gamble by Brendan Simms

    have not read the book being discussed. what is the consensus on extracting a DoW by Japan on the USSR?
  4. USSR gets absolute victory in the Winter War, effects on WW2.

    do not want to offer speculation that this scenario is favorable or advantageous for Germany however it might have forced a more limited war on them, their later Panther-Wotan Line about as far as they get, with a capture of Leningrad replacing Stalingrad (in the timeline.) that is a scenario...
  5. Japan declares war on germany july 1941

    it seems the Japanese regime (as it existed) could more plausibly improve relations with the USSR than with the US/UK? we are way out in speculative territory here but the Allies would (likely) only embrace Japan if the USSR continued their collaboration with Germany? (I've always cited trade...
  6. Japan declares war on germany july 1941

    possibly this could happen if Nazi Germany had backed the Vichy regime over Indochina and revived their cooperation with KMT China, by Sept. 1940, Japan had remained out of the war with GB for a year. (not speculating Vichy France and/or KMT China are joining the Axis, just that the Nazis might...
  7. USSR gets absolute victory in the Winter War, effects on WW2.

    what might the Soviets do in the aftermath of an absolute victory over Finland? would they be more adventurous than historical?
  8. WI: Vichy Without Petain

    IDK Lebrun was elected again in 1939, so he might be deemed useful to retain as a figurehead (or fall guy)
  9. WI: Vichy Without Petain

    think the continued control over the French fleet would, if possible, be even more important and Adm. Darlan would be the leader.
  10. Barbarossa without the Great Purge

    IDK, I have the opposite unpopular opinion, that absent (at least some) purge pre-invasion, one could be launched after the invasion? maybe/likely not in 1941, but afterwards, harming the Soviet resurgence.
  11. Indian independence trough communist revolution in 20s or 30s?

    not the expert on the subject but a religious civil war or strife might be more realistic than a Communist led revolution? Subhash Chandra Bose did go first to the USSR but my understanding the Soviets were not receptive?
  12. What if the evacuation of Dunkirk had failed?

    it seems they could reach a deal with France, Belgium, and the Netherlands (keeping the Maginot Line and other fortified positions) but doubtful they would leave Denmark and Norway? this would all move out of the very speculative category if the USSR and/or Japan were making moves? (to settle...
  13. What if the evacuation of Dunkirk had failed?

    what kind of hypothetical deal could be struck between Germany and the UK? it does not seem possible that the Nazi regime would (immediately at least) withdraw from all the occupied countries like the Low Countries and Norway? my understanding Nazi Germany had zero interest in the return of any...
  14. What if the evacuation of Dunkirk had failed?

    it seems, at least for a time, there would be no need to launch any Battle of Britain? beyond the Channel warfare. would the British attack on the French fleet at Mers-el-Kebir happen under this scenario? the rationale would still be there but the British would be lacking a certain credibility...
  15. What if the evacuation of Dunkirk had failed?

    while my postings on this subject are endorsing caution on the German side , if we start with a German victory at Dunkirk, a large majority of the BEF captured, there is no way to see it other than a catastrophe for GB. who knows what the Vichy regime, the USSR, and Japan would do? with a much...
Top